It’s Time To Arrest Ultra-Orthodox Jews Who Delay Flights Over Seating

Yet again, the takeoff of a flight from New York to Israel was delayed because haredi (ultra-Orthodox) male Jewish passengers refused to sit next to women because their faith forbids it. The Dec. 20 El Al flight’s takeoff was delayed for 30 minutes when haredi men balked at sitting between two women, and other passengers refused to accommodate them in protest until one passenger finally relented.

In October, a Delta flight was delayed after haredim refused to sit with members of the opposite sex, resulting in the plane arriving an hour late. In September, a group of haredim turned another El Al flight into a nightmare when they stood in the aisles rather than sit next to members of the opposite sex:

It seems that after takeoff a large portion of the haredi travelers took to the aisle to pray which, according to their fellow travelers, crowded the aisle and caused the flight to be unbearable.

“I went to the bathroom and it was a mission impossible, the noise was endless,” [a passenger named] Galit said.

By any measure, the haredis’ behavior is an asinine display.  That one would board a plane fully expecting the crew and passengers to accommodate their wish to not be seated next to a member of half the human race is entitlement in the extreme. And yet not only are these unruly passengers who are disturbing the peace not kicked off the plane and arrested, but they are accommodated because they say those three magic words that in one breath excuse a host of idiocy, ignorance, and irrationality: “It’s my faith.

This country has long debated the location of the boundary dividing the freedom to exercise religion and the freedom to be unmolested by religious interference. While this demarcation is not always clear and seems to shift from time to time depending on whims of the judiciary, the cases described above are so outrageously violative of this boundary, that it’s simply reckless to keep tolerating more instances of them.

Since haredi men aren’t likely to stop being sexist troglodytes anytime soon, the best way to handle haredim who refuse to take their seats is to arrest them in accordance with federal law which states,

“[N]o person may assault, threaten, intimidate, or interfere with a crewmember in the performance of the crewmember’s duties aboard an aircraft being operated.”

Refusing to take one’s seat and delaying a flight is absolutely interfering with the ability of crewmembers to perform their duties, not to mention a safety issue, disturbing the peace, and perhaps even a false imprisonment of crew and passengers.

Because this keeps happening, at least some haredis have obviously not seen fit to take the steps necessary beforehand to ensure they’ll be able to have the seating arrangement they want. Then again, in the personal responsibility department, many haredis are lacking. As a group, they disproportionately rely on welfare payments from the government so that they may spend their time doing the very practical business of studying the Torah all day. In this state of affairs, only 45% of haredi men in Israel are actually employed, compared to 61% of haredi women. This aversion to work has predictably put immense strain on the Israeli welfare system. And yet it is tolerated.

It’s my faith.

It may be their faith, but it’s also other people’s money and time. Like those who try to practice sharia in secular countries, these haredis need to be reminded that this is not their own personal theocracy where everyone else is expected to accommodate their strange, ignorant, and stupid — yes, I dare call them stupid — beliefs. And if they cannot or will not learn this, if they insist on delaying flights, or segregating city buses, or doing any number of things that are so grossly discriminatory, unruly, and a threat to public order and peace, then they should be arrested and charged just like any other unruly passenger would be.

Not only will this allow other passengers to travel on time and in peace, but it will send the offenders to more accommodative confined spaces where they can spend a night or two with members of the same sex.

Follow me on twitter

Photo credit: Amit Ben Natan



So, these men did not have the capability to pre-book a flight for a block of seats since they refused to sit in a seat next to a woman? These men had not the intelligence to realize that there is no such thing as an all-male (or all-female flight, for that matter) on any commercial airline in existence, operating on American soil?

These men would rather hold up a plane and the other passenger’s destination because of their religious beliefs?

If this was a group of Black American women who refused to sit down in their seats, and clear the aisle, I am sure they would have been thrown off the plane, charged with a federal offense, and arrested. That these men were able to hold up this flight, whether for 30 minutes, 6 hours, or 11 hours, shows the lack of will on the part of the airline.

The men were finally accommodated by an American passenger who agreed to switch seats.

Personally, if I was on that plane I would not have relinquished my seat.

I paid for it, it is what I expected when I booked my flight, and I would have the right to sit in peace and not have my comfort torn to shreds by people who obviously have utter contempt for one-half of the world’s human population.

I do not care if they are ultra-Orthodox Jews, if they are fundamentalist Muslims, if they are fundamentalist Christians, or whatever.

It is now fourteen years into the 21ST Century, and facts do have to be faced: women live in this world, and—gasp!—have the right to go about their daily lives, and that includes booking a flight without the fear of Stone Age/Pre-Cambrian behavior exhibited towards them. If they are so offended at the sight or presence of women, take up a collection and buy their own airline, then they can sit wherever they want.

These men should have been taken off the plane for disruptive behavior. They were the ones who refused to take their seats. They were the ones who caused the flight delay, at least according to the American laws that govern all flights, domestic and international, in the United States:


  • The repercussions for passengers who engage in unruly behavior can be substantial. They can be fined by FAA or prosecuted on criminal charges.
  • As part of the FAA’s Reauthorization Bill (April 16, 2000) FAA can propose up to $25,000 per violation for unruly passenger cases. Previously, the maximum civil penalty per violation was $1,100. One incident can result in multiple violations.



As for the airline asking passengers to accommodate these men, the airlines set a dangerous precedent. The flight captain should have not allowed this abusive behavior to occur, and should have instructed the crew to call TSA to eject the disruptive haredi passengers. No passenger should have the power to decide where another passenger sits. No passenger should decide who should be on a plane with them, whether that other passenger is Black, White, Christian, Muslim, Hindu, or ultra-Orthodox Jew.If these men are always allowed to get their way now, what about future flights booked? Should all passengers be removed from the plane because any religious group is offended by a fellow human being’s existence? Should all passengers be removed because of some sexist/racist belief in their own deluded superiority?

It would be the airline’s fault for allowing this disruption to occur and be prolonged the way it went down. Once given an inch, a mile would definitely be taken.

If you give a mouse a cookie. . . . .

If you give a pig a pancake . . . .  . .

If you give. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .


Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s